Original Article Written by Myra Ehrman, RN, BA, BS, MScN, on behalf of the Health Education Committee, CKCSCC. Originally Published in The Cavalier King Charles Spaniel Club of Canada Newsletter,"Quotes", in May, 1998
First, the disclaimers. The applicability to Cavaliers of any findings in the studies cited below has not been confirmed by any veterinary experts, nor have I seen anything in writing which targets Cavaliers as a group which could benefit from taking Coenzyme Q10 (which is sometimes abbreviated as CoQ10). As always, please consult your own veterinarian before changing or adding to your dogís treatment plan, and certainly do not stop giving it any prescribed medications in favour of Coenzyme Q10.
Those disclaimers being stated up front aside, my personal experience and the number of
positive studies cited below which cite beneficial outcomes from administering Coenzyme
Q10 led me to write this article. My fellow Health Education Committee members also
encouraged me to share the news.
I had first heart about Coenzyme Q10 from a fellow surfer on the internet, probably
about a year and a half ago. Since we have a Cavalier who has severe MVD, I thought
Iíd try it. Sheís been getting Coenzyme Q10, along with some other additives and
her prescribed medications, for at least that long. Her dosage is half of a 60 mg capsule,
or 30 mg, every evening. Coenzyme Q10 can be readily purchased as capsules at health food
stores; I just mix the powder in with her wet food.
The citations came from my research on the internet (http://www.pharmanord.dk/pnrm/15.html#1520
and http://www.pharmanord.dk/pnrm/8.html#829
for those who want to see for themselves). This is a sample only of all the abstracts
on Coenzyme Q10. So as not to alter any of the intended meaning of the abstract content, I
will quote specific sentences selected exactly as presented in these documents. Note the
studies quoted were done on people. Definitions of medical terminology will be provided
after the quoted passages to aid in understanding. The major source of definitions is the Encyclopedia
and Dictionary of Medicine and Nursing by Benjamin F. Miller, M.D. and Claire Brackman
Keane, R.N., B.S.
A-1510
Mortensen SA:
Perspectives on Therapy of Cardiovascular Diseases with CoQ10
Clin Investig: 71:S116-23 (1993)
"A defective myocardial energy supply ñ due to lack of substrates and/or
essential cofactors and a poor utilization efficiency of oxygen ñ may be a common
final pathway in the progression of myocardial diseases of various etiologies. The
vitamin-like, essential substance Coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10) has a key role in the oxidative
phosphorylationÖ. . the tissue CoQ10 deficiency was significantly restored by oral
therapy, 100 mg CoQ10 daily (dissolved in soy-bean oil and administered in soft gelatine
capsules). In a series of 40 patients with heart failure of various origin at
Rigshospitalet nearly two thirds revealed clinical improvement, most pronounced in
patients with dilated cardiomyopathy. Double-blind placebo-controlled trials have
definitely confirmed that coenzyme Q10 has a place as adjunctive treatment in heart
failure with beneficial effects on the clinical outcome, the patientsí physical
activity, and their quality of life. The positive results have been above and beyond the
clinical status obtained from treatment with traditional principles ñ including
angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors."
Substrate ñ a compound whose chemical transformation is catalyzed by an enzyme
Oxidative phosphorylation ñ a specific biochemical process
Angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors (ACEs) ñ a class of drugs which causes
vasodilation (increase in the dilation of blood vessels) and decreasing fluid retention in
order to decrease the workload of the heart. Enalapril maleate (Enacard, Vasotec) and
Benazeprit (Fortekor) are examples of ACE medications.
A-1512
Lampertico M; Comis S:
Italian Multicenter Study on the Efficacy and Safety of C0Q10 as Adjuvant Therapy in
Heart Failure
Clin Investig: 71:S129-33 (1993)
"A decade of international research on CoQ10 has shown that this
drug is effective in reducing the symptoms of cardiac heart failure in patients with
C.H.FÖ.RESULTS: concomitant administration of CoQ10 decreased dypsnea at rest,
exertional dyspnea, fatigue and weakness, pulmonary rales and ankle edema. Also HR and BP
were reduced. Side effects were very limited (0.4 %), mostly related to G.I. disorders.
CONCLUSIONS: CoQ10 is a powerful and safe therapeutic agent in patients with C.H.F."
C.H.F. ñ Congestive Heart Failure
Dypsnea ñ labored or difficulty breathing (exertional means during
physical exertion)
Rales ñ an abnormal respiratory sound heard in auscultation and
indicating some pathologic condition
Edema (also spelled oedema, British style) ñ an abnormal
accumulation of fluid in the intercellular spaces of the body
HR ñ heart rate
BP ñ blood pressure
A-1513
Morisco C; Trimarco B; Condorelli M
Effect of Coenzyme Q10 Therapy in Patients with Congestive Heart
Failure: a Long Term Multicenter Randomized Study:
Clin Investig: 71:S134-6 (1993)
"The improved cardiac function in patients with CHF treated with CoenzymeQ10
supports the hypothesis that this condition is characterized by mitochondrial dysfunction
and energy starvation, and therefore that it may be ameliorated by Coenzyme Q10
supplementationÖ.episodes of pulmonary oedema or cardiac asthma were reduced in the
control group (20 vs 51 and 97 vs 198, respectively, both p<0.001), as compared to the
placebo group. Our results demonstrate that the addition of coenzyme Q10 to conventional
therapy significantly reduces hospitalization for worsening heart failure and the
incidence of serious complications in patients with congestive heart failure."
A-1517
Baggio E: Gandini R; Plancer C; Passeri N; Carmosino G;
Italian Multicenter Study on the Efficacy and Safety of C0Q10 as Adjuvant Therapy in
Heart Failure (interim analysis)
Clin Investig: 71:S145-9 (1993)
"We investigated the efficacy and safety of CoQ10 adjuvant
treatment in congestive heart failure which had been diagnosed at least 6 months
previously and treated with standard therapy. ÖPreliminary results on 1113 patients,
mean age 69.4 years, show a low incidence of side effects, 11 adverse events were reported
in 8 (0.74%) patients of which only 6 events were correlated to the test treatment. After
3 months of test treatment the percentage of patients with improvement in clinical signs
and symptoms was as follows: cyanosis (81%), edema (76.9%), pulmonary rales (78.4%),
hepatomegaly (49.3%), jugular reflux (81.5%), dypsnoea (54.2%), palpitations (75.7%),
sweating (82.4%), arrhythmia (62.2%), insomnia (60.2%), vertigo (73%), nocturia (50.7%).
Moreover, we observed a contemporary improvement of at least 3 symptoms in 54% of
patients; this could be interpreted as an index of improved quality of life."
Cyanosis ñ a bluish discoloration of skin and mucous membranes due
to excessive concentration of reduced hemoglobin in the blood
Hepatomegaly ñ enlargement of the liver
Jugular reflux ñ swelling of the jugular vein induced by pressure
over the liver seen in heart failure
Palpitation ñ a heartbeat that is unusually rapid, strong or
irregular enough to make a person aware of it
Arrhythmia ñ Variation from the normal heartbeat
Vertigo ñ dizziness
Nocturia ñ excessive urination at night.
Wouldnít it be interesting if research done on people turns out to benefit our
dogs for a change?
If anyone else decides to add CoQ10 to your MVD-affected dogís diet, Iíd be
interested to hear from you in a few months to let me know if you are able to detect any
improvement in clinical symptoms.
Disclaimer: Your veterinarian is the most qualified person to answer all of the
questions you have about your pet's health. Nothing in this article should be construed as
medical advice regarding any individual animalís condition.
© Copyright April 19, 1999.
|